*facepalm headclutch headdesk*

Angry South Africans deny rumours of split

Dileep Premachandran in Colombo, August 17, 2006
 
Mark Boucher was incensed by the local media coverage of South Africa's pull out

Click here to send us your feedback on this issue.

South Africa's cricketers reacted angrily to suggestions that senior players had bullied the younger ones into going along with the decision to return home from the tour of Sri Lanka. They were also fuming about the local media coverage of the withdrawal, with one prominent local daily carrying the back-page headline 'South African cricketers chicken out'.

Another, the Daily Mirror published out of Colombo alleged that Mark Boucher, Shaun Pollock, Makhaya Ntini, Andrew Hall, Andre Nel and Mickey Arthur, the coach, were instrumental in the South Africans deciding to go home. The article also suggested that the decision had less to do with security, and more to do with their 2-0 loss in the Test series, and a fear of similar disappointments in the one-day games.

"It was a decision taken by everyone," said AB de Villiers, one of the younger players that had a lot to gain by playing here. "It was an opportunity for the young guys to play a few games in subcontinent conditions [with the Champions Trophy just two months away], and it's unfortunate that it won't happen. I'm prepared to give everything while playing for South Africa, but not my life."

de Villiers also said that those who criticised the team weren't aware of the facts of the matter. "It's nonsense to judge someone without being here in their situation. We're foreigners here, not knowing what's going on, and with bombs going off near us. The security guys are telling us to go home, and that's good enough for me."

Boucher, who was expected to captain the side during the one-day series, was incensed by the coverage, not least because it was his face that was prominently displayed beneath the chicken headline. "It's disappointing," he said, "and there's not much that you can do once such stuff is published."

Loots Bosman, the 29-year-old opening bat who was expected to get his chance here in Graeme Smith's absence, was probably the man with most to gain had South Africa stayed on. But he insisted that there was going to be only one decision after the team's security advisors told them the risk was untenable.

"Obviously, the whole situation is about safety," he told Cricinfo. "It's not a junior-senior issue. On the cricketing front, it's unfortunate, but I can't do much about it or have any control over such situations. Maybe I'll get an opportunity to represent South Africa again."

Having fielded calls all day regarding the alleged split within the ranks, Gordon Templeton, the team's media manager, also didn't mince words when asked his opinion about the stories called by the Daily News and the Daily Mirror. "Those with anything between their ears, and who understand cricket, would find such stories utterly laughable."

The team leaves Colombo on Friday morning, flying to Johannesburg via Hong Kong, but the ill-feeling that they leave behind may linger for some time.

......

Mendis criticises South Africa's pull-out

Cricinfo staff, August 17, 2006
 
Mendis : 'The government put in place presidential-level security for the team, yet they [South Africa] were not convinced'

Duleep Mendis, Sri Lanka Cricket's chief executive, has criticised South Africa's decision to pull out of the Unitech Cup following a bomb blast in Colombo on Monday. South Africa's withdrawal came after an independent security assessment by a Dubai-based firm said that "the current risk to the team is at an unacceptable level".

"I am amazed at their decision to return home," Mendis told AFP. "The government put in place presidential-level security for the team, yet they were not convinced. They took advice from a Dubai firm which is even more surprising. I did not see anyone from this firm in Colombo, yet they prepared a security report within 24 hours sitting in Dubai."

The South African Cricketers' Association (SACA) issued a statement fully supporting the decision while saying that it was an extremely difficult one to make. "This has been a very tense last three days" said Tony Irish, the Chief Executive Officer of SACA. "Graeme Smith, Jacques Kallis and I have been in constant contact with the team in Colombo while the process necessary for making the decision has taken place. It has been a very difficult time for the players, especially having to deal with the uncertainty of the situation."

"At the end of the day, you have to rely on what the security experts say and base the decisions on that. The team's security consultants, Nicholls, Steyn and Associates, have been very thorough and the independent ICC security consultants concurred with their security assessment. One cannot underestimate the difficulty of this decision, but it does show that Cricket South Africa places the emphasis on where it should be, namely the safety of the players and the national team."